The number of reserved positions for Indigenous council members on NZ local authorities is set to be cut by more than half, following a controversial legislative amendment that required municipal councils to put the fate of hard-earned Māori seats to a public vote.
Historical Context on Indigenous Representation
Māori wards, which may have one or more elected officials based on local population numbers, were created in 2001 to provide Indigenous voters the option to elect a guaranteed Māori representative in local and regional authorities. Originally, local governments were only able to create a Māori ward by first submitting it to a community referendum in their area. Communities often devoted considerable time building local support and urging their councils to establish Indigenous representation.
Legislative Shifts and Government Actions
To address this concern, the former administration permitted municipal authorities to set up a Indigenous seat without first requiring them to put it to a popular ballot.
But in 2024, the current administration overturned the policy, stating local residents ought to determine whether to establish Indigenous representation.
Referendum Results
The coalition’s law change required local authorities that had created a ward under Labour’s rules to hold binding referendums alongside the municipal polls, which ended on 11 October. Of 42 councils taking part in the referendum, 17 voted to keep their wards, and 25 to disestablish theirs – showing numerous areas opposed to reserved Indigenous seats.
The results provided “a vital step in restoring local democratic control.”
Critics however have condemned the new policy as “discriminatory” and “against Indigenous interests”. Since taking office, the current administration has implemented sweeping rollbacks to policies designed to enhance Māori health, wellbeing and representation. Officials has said it wants to end “ethnic-specific” policies, and asserts it is dedicated to improving outcomes for Māori and all New Zealanders.
Geographical Splits
Outcomes of the referendums were divided down city-country divisions – six of the seven cities required to vote supported Māori wards, while rural regions skewed heavily towards removing them.
“It’s a real shame for the Indigenous seats that had only just come in – they’re just beginning to find their footing.”
Electoral Participation and Concerns
This year’s municipal polls recorded the smallest electoral participation in 36 years, with less than a third of eligible voters participating, prompting calls for an overhaul.
This approach had been “a farce”.
Comparative Treatment
Councils are permitted to create different electoral districts – such as countryside seats – without initially mandating a community ballot. The different conditions placed on Māori wards suggested the government was singling out Māori representation.
“Well, they failed. Numerous localities have expressed strong opposition.”
This statement referred to the 17 regions that chose to keep their wards.